20 Best Places Where you Can Sell your Baseball Cards for Money

If you’re looking to make some money from your baseball cards, then having to sell them online or in a brick-and-mortar store is certainly worth considering. Here are some websites and stores to sell your baseball cards.

sell your Baseball Cards

20 Places to Sell Baseball Cards

1. eBay

This is one of the best places to sell baseball cards. This is because you can often find a buyer who’s in the market for your specific card. So if that buyer is online searching for that card, then they could see your eBay listing, and you could make a sale.

Also, because you tend to have buyers looking for specific cards or collections on eBay, it means that you can often get more cash. Now, it is free to list up to 50 items for sale on eBay.

After that though, you do need to pay $0.30 per listing. So if you have more than 50 items to sell, then do keep this in mind when you are pricing your stuff for sale.

Also, you need to pay a 10% commission fee when your cards sell. So, again, just keep these fees in mind when you are listing your stuff for sale on eBay.

2. Local card shops

Okay, while there may not be quite as many local card shops around as there once were, this is still a worthwhile option to sell your Baseball Cards. If you do have a card shop nearby, then you should definitely consider asking them if they’ll purchase your old baseball cards.

You can find local card stores by going to Google, or whatever search engine you use, and then entering the phrase, “baseball card stores near me,” or “sports card stores near me,” into the search bar. Hit enter, and it will show you if they are any stores near you that sell sports cards. Call ahead to check if the store purchases baseball cards.

Keep in mind that selling to local card stores won’t always get you as much as you would if you were to sell on sites like eBay. This is because these stores usually purchase cards for a lower price than their value so that they can resell them at a higher price.

3. Yard sales

Yard sales are a good option to Sell your Baseball Cards because you can tap into a market of people who may not shop online. Plus, you get to set your own prices.

If you have some less valuable cards and you’re just looking to get some quick cash for them, then I would recommend having a yard sale. You can get cash on the sport for your baseball cards.

4. Craigslist

Craigslist is another great option to Sell your Baseball Cards because you can list stuff for sale on there for free. And, you don’t have to pay commission fees when you sell your baseball cards.

5. Reddit (r/baseballcards)

Reddit is a good place to find buyers because it has threads for pretty much every hobby/niche/interest. So, it’s a great place to list your baseball cards for sale.

There’s actually a subreddit called r/baseballcards where people share sports cards, and collectibles, and discuss baseball cards in general. It actually allows you to list cards for sale on there. Just be sure to follow the subreddit’s rules.

You are not allowed to post links to cards for sale elsewhere. Instead, you must offer them for sale through the subreddit. The subreddit recommends using PayPal for taking payment. Visit the subreddit to learn more about selling your baseball cards on there.

6. eBid

Another place to Sell your Baseball Cards is on eBid. This is a good alternative to eBay if you’re looking for more places to sell. It has 4.2 stars on Trustpilot, which is a rating of “Great.”’

So, it’s a legit place to sell your baseball cards. Like eBay, eBid is an online auction website where you can sell your sports cards and memorabilia.

7. Pawnshops

If you want to know who buys baseball cards near you, then try your local pawn shop. Many pawn shops purchase sports cards making them a good option.

Since pawn shops want to purchase items at a lower price in order to resell them for a profit, they generally won’t offer you the highest price for your cards.

8. Dean’s Cards

Dean’s Cards is a company that sells more than 1,000 vintage baseball cards per day! And, the company maintains an inventory of more than 1 million cards, making it the largest online vendor for vintage cards.

According to Dean’s Cards, because the company sells directly, it can usually pay more money for your cards than you would get elsewhere. You can get a free appraisal of your baseball cards by completing the form on the site.

Dean’s Cards purchase almost any card from 1969 and before, and most complete sets through 1985. Aside from some complete sets, it rarely purchases cards that are newer than 1980, as the site says that many of them do not hold enough value.

You can mail your collection to the company. Its bid software generates an offer that’s based on the current market prices and availability and it sends you its best offer upfront. Now, if you don’t like the offer, the company will mail your collection back to you. Sellers, according to Dean’s Cards, end up accepting its bid more than 80% of the time.

9. The Cardboard Connection

Another option you can try is selling your cards to The Cardboard Connection.

You can sell your old baseball cards or your entire sports card collection for cash to The Cardboard Connection. The company has facilitated the sale of more than $1 million worth of sports cards and collectibles. It purchases lots of different sports cards, including baseball cards.

You can simply complete the form on the website, and The Cardboard Connection will refer you to one of its industry-leading buying partners.

When you have submitted the form, The Cardboard Connection and/or one or more of its vetted network of buying partners will contact you in 1 to 2 business days to learn more about your collection, and to get the buying process rolling.

According to the site, most cards from the 1980s and 1990s have little value, and its buyers are mainly looking for vintage cards from before 1974.

It’s definitely another site to consider as it gets your cards in front of different buyers!

10. Just Collect

Next, we have Just Collect. This is a website where you can sell vintage sports cards for cash. It buys most vintage cards, which are those from 1979 or earlier. It only buys certain modern cards, so those produced after 1979. You can learn more about what types of cards Just Collect purchases by visiting the website.

You can use the free appraisal form on the site to get started selling your cards to the company and to find out what your collection is worth.

You can mail your collection to Just Collect, and it will pay for shipping and insurance. That’s pretty great, right?

If you prefer to sell in person, then the company also allows you to drive to one of its appraisal locations or they can drive to you.

And, if you are far away, and have a big collection, the company may even fly out to meet with you.

11. Webstore

Webstore is an online auction site that allows you to sell stuff in multiple categories. It has a category just for sports cards and memorabilia, so you can sell your baseball cards there. Since Webstore has an impressive 4.1 stars on Trustpilot, which is a rating of “Great,” it’s a legit place to sell baseball cards.

The other good thing about selling through the platform is that it doesn’t charge you fees to list your cards for sale on there. And, it doesn’t charge you any value fees or commissions either, so you get to keep 100% of the selling price.

12. Kruk Cards

With Kruk Cards, you can get paid for your baseball cards. It’s been buying and selling for over 30 years, making it a well-established place to sell.

The company will assess your cards and give you a quote. It purchases collections large and small. It’s definitely one to consider.

Read Also:

13. Bonanza

Another place where you can sell baseball cards is at Bonanza. It’s another auction site where you can list baseball cards for sale. Since Bonanza only features around 25,000 sellers, it’s much less competitive than eBay, which has more than 25 million sellers.

sell your Baseball Cards

Aside from less competition, Bonanza is also good because it doesn’t charge you to list items on there. When you sell your cards, the site does take a 3.5% commission. So do keep that in mind when you are pricing cards for sale.

14. 2nd Markets

2nd Markets is a website where you can sell your vintage baseball and sports card collection. It has more than 30 years of experience with buying from the public. According to the site, no collection is too large.

2nd Markets only buys large collections, rather than single items or small collections unless they are very valuable. So if you don’t have a large collection of cards to sell, then try one of the other options on the list.

15. SportsCardPro

Next on the list we have SportsCardPro. You can list baseball cards for sale on there. It’s free to list stuff on the site. However, when your cards do sell, you will have to pay a payment processing fee of 2.9% + 30¢. You’re paid to your PayPal account.

16. Atomic Mall

Atomic Mall is an online marketplace, like eBay, where you can sell your baseball cards. The website is rated “Great” on Trustpilot, so it’s a legit place to make money from your baseball cards. You can set your own price, which is good!

17. Check Out My Collectibles COMC

COMC is an online marketplace for buying and selling sports cards, comics, gaming cards, and more. You can create a free account on the site, and then send your cards to the company. You can even set your asking price and respond to offers from buyers.

Once your cards sell, you can choose how you would like to get your earnings. There are a few options available, including:

  • You can convert the store credit you get into cash.
  • You can redeem your store credit to buy sealed boxes and cases.
  • Or, you can use the store credit to buy other trading cards or collectibles.

18. DA Card World

DA Card World is another site where you can sell your baseball cards online. The company buys sealed boxes and cases of sports cards. And, it also purchases modern sports card singles.

19. Sports Card Forum

Another forum where you can list cards for sale is the Sports Card Forum. The forum has a section for buying and selling baseball cards. So you could post your cards for sale on there.

People even post cards that they are looking for on the forum as well. So you could have a card that someone is already looking to buy.

20. Blowout Cards Forum

Another option to consider is the Blowout Cards Forum. It’s a forum where people can discuss collecting sports cards and trading cards.

It actually has a discussion on buying, selling, and trading baseball cards. So you could post your baseball cards for sale on there, and see what people are looking to purchase.

The good thing with selling through these types of forums is that you can often find targeted buyers many of whom are looking to purchase specific cards. Plus, you can set your own rates within reason of course.

Are Baseball Cards Worth Money?

The money you can get for your collection depends on which cards you have.

Vintage cards which are made before 1979 are more valuable than cards from the 1980s and 1990s. Cards made in the 1980s and after were mass produced meaning that they have little value.

There are some exceptions though. A modern card can be valuable if it is a current or future Hall of Famer’s rookie card that’s in pristine condition, features a printing error, or it’s personally autographed by the player himself.

An example of a modern card that has value is the 1993 SP Derek Jeter rookie card. These exceptions are rare though. Whatever your collection includes modern or vintage cards, you can sell them somewhere.

What Are the Most Valuable Baseball Cards?

These are the top 5 most valuable baseball cards:

  1. 1909-11 T206 White Border Honus Wagner: Estimated Value: $4,000,000
  2. 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle Estimated Value: $2,500,000
  3. 1916 (M101-5) Sporting News Babe Ruth Rookie Card: Estimated Value: $1,350,000
  4. 1916 (M101-4) Sporting News #151 Babe Ruth Rookie Card: Estimated Value: $1,350,000
  5. 1909-11 T206 Ty Cobb Tobacco (Ty Cobb Back): Estimated Value: $1,100,000

sell your Baseball Cards

Okay, so whether you have a large collection of cards or just a few to sell, give the places on our list a try. Even if you have more modern cards, it’s still worth selling them because even if you only get a little cash, you’ve still made money from cards you no longer want!

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *