– Leftist vs Liberal –
Leftist vs Liberal Everything from left-moderate to liberal to leftist can be found on the left. All of these terminologies may be perplexing to someone who feels themselves to be on the left or right side of the political spectrum.
It’s possible that you’re a liberal without ever recognizing it. You can be liberal without being a leftist.
Here’s everything you need to know about the terms liberal and leftist, as well as the contrasts between them.
Liberal vs. Leftist (What’s The Difference?)
Liberals and leftists are both on the left side of the political spectrum, yet there is a significant gap between them.
When it comes to economics, the main contrast is that liberals believe in more conservative methods. Leftists feel that the government should be more involved in the economy.
Liberals, for example, feel that the wealthiest should receive more tax incentives and that government control should be reduced overall.
Leftists feel that the wealthy should pay a higher tax rate to help support other social programs that benefit those who do not benefit from capitalism.
How Did Liberalism Begin?
Understanding the history of each of these ideologies can help you better comprehend the differences between liberalism and leftism.
Liberalism may be traced back several centuries, but in terms of modern politics, 19th-century England is the crucial period to consider.
There were two major political parties in England.
The Tories primarily represented the Crown’s and the countryside’s interests.
The Whigs represented the merchants and aristocracies. Left and right were not notions until the mid-nineteenth century.
In today’s world, neither of those parties would fit into either of those groups.
However, by the 1840s, the Tories and Whigs had lost their ability to accurately represent the people.
This is due to the fact that Britain was becoming more industrialized. To deal with the new difficulties that society was experiencing, it needed fresh thinking.
The title “new liberals” was given to these new intellectuals because of the views they proposed. Liberals wanted to determine if capitalism benefited both workers and factory owners.
Origin of Liberalism
They believed in Adam Smith’s concept of the Invisible Hand, which he introduced in The Wealth of Nations.
This Invisible Hand would steer the market to the workers’ advantage.
The plan was for a factory to open and hire additional employees. The worker would then be able to spend their wages on additional items.
To meet those demands, a new factory is established, and they hired more people. The cycle continues in a peaceful manner.
The theory was that if they could get this idea to operate quickly enough, using low taxes and free trade laws, the system would raise the worker’s value while keeping the price of commodities cheap.
The issue is that the society of the 1800s is not the same as the society of today.
Taxes were only raised in the 1800s when wars broke out. As a result, they generally avoided wars as much as possible.
This is in stark contrast to today when protracted wars generate enormous riches for a small number of people. The Whigs lost control, and a new party called the Liberal Party rose to prominence.
The Liberal Party’s role was to keep the economic cycle rolling with minimal engagement. Until World War I, this tradition persisted for more than 70 years.
All of that changed in the early twentieth century when a new political party arose.
This political party, known as the Labor Party, questioned whether liberals were doing enough for society. The term “leftism” was coined in this way.
How Did Leftism Begin?
Leftism has its origins in England’s Labor Party. They witnessed poverty that has worsened over time as a result of capitalism’s liberal structure.
They felt Adam Smith’s Invisible Hand benefited industrialists at the expense of workers. This was not the intention of the country when it embraced the concept.
It resulted in the poor being left behind and fighting to make ends meet while the state did nothing to assist them. The Liberal Party would be replaced by the Labor Party.
They implemented policies that are now widely regarded as leftist. Disability insurance, the National Health Service, and old-age pensions are examples of these policies.
In addition, they raised income taxes. These concepts made their way to the United States across the Atlantic Ocean.
President Franklin Delano Roosevelt was looking for ways to help the country get out of poverty during the Great Depression.
A leftist proposal known as The New Deal played a role in his election. Republican Herbert Hoover was his biggest opponent at the time.
More Insight on the Origin of Leftism
FDR promoted liberal views on the market and the role of government in society. Everyone in the country was promised a stimulus package under the New Deal.
It was the first time that inhabitants of the country received direct financial assistance from the government to which they had paid their taxes.
Roosevelt would go on to establish a number of other social welfare initiatives aimed at assisting and protecting the working class.
During World War II, these schemes would continue to be a part of the political landscape.
Even 40 years later, Presidents would incorporate elements of leftism into their electoral platforms.
President Dwight D. Eisenhower, for example, increased Social Security and provided financial assistance to low-income families.
Leftist vs Liberalism
In the 1970s, some economists advocated for a return to a free-market economy. Ronald Reagan, the then-presidential contender, echoed this sentiment.
He desired to eliminate all market constraints imposed by the government. He believed that by doing so, the market would be able to work its magic and benefit everyone.
Reagan was a firm believer in Adam Smith’s concept of the Invisible Hand guiding the market and, as a result, society.
Therefore, he wasn’t the only politician who desired a return to a more liberal economy. Margaret Thatcher, the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, also expressed her thoughts on the subject.
They battled against the creation of unions and unions in general, as well as lowering taxes for the wealthy, between the two of them.
They also reduced the funding for a number of social programs, if not completely eliminating them.
Companies privatized and took utilities and other industries that were formerly handled by the government over. As a result, the neoliberal era began.
Leftist vs Liberal Political Compass
Although these tactics originated on the Republican side of the political spectrum, they were also adopted on the left.
President Bill Clinton recognized neoliberalism’s popularity and promised to cut welfare services even further.
He also completed the North American Free Trade Agreement, which was started by George H. W. Bush during his presidency. Clinton gathered a new breed of democrats he dubbed the New Democrats.
Tony Blair, a left-leaning politician, intended to carry on Thatcher’s market-opening work.
He wanted to modernize the welfare system by reducing it and keeping government involvement as low as possible in the economy.
All of these changes have resulted in the current economic situation.
Liberalism And Leftism Today
As a result, both principles are brought up to date. Certain political figures have features of liberalism, while others have elements of leftism.
Joe Biden is a Democrat who also happens to be a liberal. He fought for the Affordable Care Act and backed NAFTA as a law.
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) is a market-based system rather than truly universal healthcare. During his presidential campaign, he did, however, accept several Marxist principles for his program.
That’s because he’s well aware that many Democrats are interested in the leftist ideologies promoted by other politicians.
He needed to unite liberal and leftist ideas about the country together in order to beat incumbent President Donald Trump in the election. Biden, on the other hand, is a liberal at heart.
Bernie Sanders is a well-known leftist politician. He supports universal healthcare, which would be paid for by taxes on the wealthy and other sources.
Difference Between Leftist vs Liberal
He also supports a number of additional social programs aimed at assisting the working class and others who are unable to engage in capitalism. Today’s leftists feel that banks and lending processes should be regulated.
They want corporations to contribute to the society that buys their products by paying their fair share of taxes.
Today, the choice between liberalism and leftism boils down to the economy and how the government spends those dollars.
Liberals advocate for open markets and low taxes. Leftists advocate for regulation that taxes the wealthy and helps pay for social programs for the poor and disadvantaged.
To help discern between prospective presidential contenders, it’s critical to recognize the key contrasts between them.
Even whether someone calls themselves a Democrat or a Republican, knowing if they’re a leftist or a liberal can help you figure out what kind of politician they are.
You can forecast the types of bills they’ll introduce or reject, as well as the changes they’ll make to the country if you grasp that.
What is the Difference Between a Leftist vs Liberal?
Answering this question is critical to comprehending America’s and the West’s current crisis. However, few appear to be capable of doing so. As a starting point, consider the following.
The first thing to know is that the two have almost nothing in common.
On the contrary, liberalism shares far more similarities with conservatism than with leftism. The left has so effectively appropriated the term “liberal” that almost everyone—liberals, leftists, and conservatives alike—believes they are synonymous.
They aren’t, however. Let’s take a look at some key examples.
The most obvious of the many moral differences between liberalism and leftism is race.
The liberal position on race was essential that the color of one’s skin is unimportant. Only racists, according to liberals of a generation ago, believed that race is intrinsically significant.
To the left, however, the idea that race is unimportant is racist in and of itself.
As a result, the University of California considers the statement, “There is only one race, the human race,” to be racist.
Liberals have always been pro-capitalism, recognizing it for what it is: the only economical means of lifting great numbers out of poverty.
Liberals did often view the government as able to play a bigger role in lifting people out of poverty than conservatives, but they were never opposed to capitalism, and they were never for socialism.
Opposition to capitalism and advocacy of socialism are leftist values.
Liberals firmly believed in the nation-state, whether it be the United States, the United Kingdom, or France.
The left has always been opposed to nationalism because it is based on class solidarity rather than national solidarity.
The left despises nationalism, viewing it as intellectual and moral primitivism at best and a path to fascism at worst.
Liberals have always wished to safeguard American sovereignty and borders. The concept of open borders would have been equally repugnant to a liberal as it is to a conservative.
The left-wing writers of Superman comics had Superman announce a few years ago, “I intend to speak before the United Nations tomorrow and inform them that I am renouncing my American citizenship,” which is emblematic of our time.
As a result, liberals were fervently committed to racial integration. The existence of black dormitories and separate black graduations on university campuses should sicken liberals.
Liberals were aware of and appreciated America’s Judeo-Christian roots. They went to church or synagogue themselves, or at the very least appreciated that the majority of their fellow Americans did.
The left’s contempt for religion (except for Islam today) is not something with which a liberal would ever have identified.
American and Western civilization will perish if the left is not defeated. However, the left will not be defeated unless good liberals recognize this and join the fight.
Which Political Figures Are Liberals?
Members of both parties can be liberals, regardless of whether they are Democrats or Republicans.
Here are a few well-known liberal politicians.
1. Rudy Giuliani
Many people do not consider him a liberal because he is a Republican. This is because the term “liberal” is used in the American lexicon to refer to anyone who is a member of the Democratic Party.
Giuliani, on the other hand, is a liberal.
When looking at his historical record, it is clear that he has slashed taxes on businesses on a regular basis. His ties to Donald Trump and big corporations also place him firmly in the liberal camp.
2. Newt Gingrich
Gingrich is a liberal Republican who is also a Republican. In 1994, he was a member of the Republican Party, which advocated for less government intervention in different parts of life.
He also voted in favor of welfare reforms in order to cut costs. Gingrich also advocated for lower taxes for corporations and the rich, and he is a liberal in heart, despite being regarded as one of conservatism’s titans.
3. Mitt Romney
Romney has elements of both a liberal and a leftist. Many in his own party accused him of being a liberal Republican, but they really mean Democrat.
Romney is a liberal because of his business background. He also implemented and fought for policies that slashed taxes on businesses and the rich while he was governor.
4. Mike Pence
Mike Pence served in Congress and as governor of Indiana before becoming Trump’s Vice President.
He is a devout conservative Republican who, yet, has liberal economic views.
He is a firm believer in a small government and lower taxes for the wealthy and companies.
5. Bill Clinton
Clinton, who served as the Democratic President of the United States, is credited with bringing liberal Democrats into Congress.
He didn’t do much to change policies because he was focused on continuing Reagan’s liberal economic policies.
By cutting expenditures for welfare programs and enacting tax reforms, he embraced a liberal economy even more. Clinton is a Democrat, but he is a liberal Democrat.
6. Hillary Clinton
Hillary Clinton, like her husband, is a liberal Democrat. She holds the same ideas as her husband, who was president at the time.
At the very least, she tends to support centrist legislation. Clinton was also a proponent of tax cuts and welfare reform.
7. Nancy Pelosi
Nancy Pelosi, like Mitt Romney, is a political figure who is both leftist and liberal.
In many aspects, she is a supporter of leftist beliefs, but she has also been a supporter of the liberal agenda.
Part of this could be attributable to her proclivity for putting forth the effort to get things passed through Congress.
She has had to make compromises in order to obtain other desires. Regardless, she is a liberal because she voted for laws that reformed welfare and increased taxes on working families.
8. Barack Obama
Barack Obama is another well-known liberal politician.
There’s a lot of disagreement about whether Obama was a Republican or a Democrat. That perplexity is most likely due to his liberal viewpoints.
Although he has advocated for leftist ideas such as universal healthcare, his approach to achieving it was more liberal than leftist.
During the 2008 financial crisis, he was also liberal in terms of bailing out banks and businesses.
He aided in the deregulation of the market and the reduction of taxes in order to keep businesses afloat.
One could argue, however, that all of that freedom is what caused the problem in the first place.
Obama was a leftist in many aspects of his political beliefs, but he also had liberal tendencies.
9. Evan Bayh
The former governor of Indiana is a liberal as well.
Despite campaigning to be the Democratic presidential nominee in 2008, he eventually dropped out of the race. Bayh is a Democrat who favors the center.
He supports some welfare programs, but not at the expense of the wealthy. During his tenure as governor of Indiana, he implemented numerous tax breaks for Indiana residents.
In fact, he is responsible for the state’s largest tax cut in history. Bayh’s beliefs classify him as a liberal.
10. Donald Trump
There’s no doubt about it: Donald Trump is a liberal.
His platform has always been about cutting taxes for the wealthy and slashing welfare programs. He has also attempted to keep the government out of other businesses.
He even pushed the country back toward isolationism by withdrawing from the UN. These are all characteristics of a liberal.
What Political Figures Are Leftists?
While there are obviously many famous politicians who are liberals, there are also many politicians who are leftists.
More politicians with leftist leanings are entering the mainstream as the progressive party gains traction and attracts more members.
Here are a few leftist political figures.
1. Mitt Romney
As previously stated, there are instances in which Mitt Romney expresses leftist leanings. For example, he supported gay marriage and abortion.
For many years, he advocated for gun control. Because these beliefs are leftist in nature, Romney is both a liberal and a leftist.
2. Barack Obama
Although many of his policies were liberal, he also held some leftist ideals that placed him in that camp. In its early stages, the Affordable Care Act was quite leftist.
It turned out to be more liberal than expected. One of the most compelling pieces of evidence pointing to Obama’s leftist tendencies is his support for gay marriage.
It was during his presidency that gay marriage was legalized. Another leftist ideal in which the government interfered with marriage rights.
In economics, Obama tended to be more liberal, but in all other areas, he tended to be more leftist.
3. Nancy Pelosi
Pelosi is another political figure who straddles both sides.
Although she is not a total leftist, she has endorsed many leftist ideas. She was a supporter of gay marriage and abortion rights.
Pelosi also supports taxing the wealthy and canceling student loans when the political climate is favorable. All of these ideas are of the leftist variety.
4. Bernie Sanders
You can’t talk about leftists without mentioning Bernie Sanders. Sanders is arguably one of the main reasons why leftism has recently gained popularity.
Sanders is unmistakably a leftist, with a focus on targeting Wall Street and taxing the wealthy.
He believes that several welfare programs should be funded in order to help society.
He believes that the government should take more active control of the economy in order to fund those programs. This includes raising taxes on the ultra-rich.
5. Elizabeth Warren
Elizabeth Warren is another leftist.
Despite being more outspoken than Sanders, she shares the same leftist ideals. She is vehemently opposed to Wall Street and believes that they should pay higher taxes.
The proceeds from these taxes should then be used to fund welfare programs. Warren is frequently associated with those on the far left of the political spectrum.
6. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
Aside from Sanders, another outspoken leftist voice is Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, also known as AOC.
AOC is best known for using Twitter to inform her followers about issues in Congress.
She frequently expresses her support for taxing the ultra-rich in order to support communities.
She believes in universal health care and other social programs. Like Sanders, she serves as the public face for politicians with leftist leanings.
7. Ayanna Pressley
Finally, Ayanna Pressley is another leftist, though far from the last.
Her leftist ideals have been focused on improving the workplace and eliminating violence against women.
She also believes in criminal justice reform and emphasizes the voices of those most affected by injustice. She, like other leftists, favors greater government control over the economy.
- Advantages and Disadvantages of Democracy in 2022
- 160 Hard Work Quotes That Will Make Your Efforts Pay Off
- 160 Hard Work Quotes That Will Make Your Efforts Pay Off
The word liberal is frequently used in the English language. It includes Democrats, but that does not necessarily imply that all Democrats are liberals. Some of them are socialists.
Leftists believe in a regulated economy, whereas liberals believe in little government oversight of the economy. Both Republicans and Democrats can be liberal, leftist, or a mix of the two.
FAQs About Leftist vs Liberalist
1. Why are the Words ‘Liberal’ and ‘Leftist’ Interchangeable?
Democratic presidential candidates have a wide range of ideas and points of view. What they don’t have in common, according to one historian, is the label “liberal.”
2. Why do Americans say ‘Liberal’ Instead of Left-Wing?
Modern liberalism in the United States (often simply referred to as liberalism in the United States) is a type of social liberalism found in American politics.
3. What Does ‘Left Liberal’ Mean in Practice?
Left-libertarianism is a political philosophy and type of libertarianism that emphasizes both individual freedom and social equality. It is also known as egalitarian libertarianism, left-wing libertarianism, or social libertarianism.
4. Does the Term ‘Liberal’ Means Left-Wing in the United States?
The US Department of Homeland Security defines “left-wing extremism” as groups that “seek to effect change through violent revolution.”
5. What’s the Difference Between a Liberal and a Democrat?
“Democrat” refers to a political party, whereas “liberal” refers to a political ideology.
More Frequently Asked Questions About Leftist vs Liberalist
6. Can you be Both Progressive and Liberal?
You certainly can. The two are inextricably linked. Progressives, on the other hand, are more daring than liberals.
7. What does it mean to be a Left-wing Liberal in the US?
Left-wing politics promotes social equality and egalitarianism and is frequently opposed to social hierarchy.
8. Is the term ‘Liberal’ Outdated?
No way, no how. It is frequently used in everyday conversation. People will understand what you mean if you say you’re a liberal.
9. What has Changed with the Definition of a Liberal in the USA?
The liberal party maintains that the government has a clear obligation to use all of its power and resources to respond to new social problems with new social controls.
10. What does the Word ‘Liberal’ mean in American Politics?
Liberals hold a variety of positions depending on how they interpret these principles, but they generally support individual rights.